Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Read It and Weep

{I had this post ready last week and had it up for about an hour before I felt guilty for exploiting my students' work and the total lack of professionalism I exhibited by putting this on display.  I have since had a change of heart.  This morning I made a special trip to campus in the 17 degree weather to collect really late work from four students. Only one kid turned in his work.  Professionalism be darned.}

It really is the most wonderful time of the year. Time for students to turn in their final writing portfolios. I had a few treasures that those of you who enjoy absurdity might like. Names have been blurred to protect the innocent.

To give you some context, the Writing Portfolio is a collection of the students' four major essays (graded or resubmitted for a revised grade) and a fifth assignment called a Writer's Reflection.

Here's what that should entail:

Tell me about where you were as a writer as you began this term.  What were your fears, weaknesses, strengths, and possibly what type of writing you felt comfortable doing prior to this semester? 
Tell your audience what your biggest accomplishments have been this term as far as your writing.  Which assignments tended to be your favorite, least favorite, most/least challenging.  Why?
Explain your typical writing process in great detail. What is your typical routine once you have been given an assignment?  I am especially interested in hearing about your revision process.  What do you do and how do you do it?
Finally, how do you see yourself as a writer in the academic discipline for which you are majoring?  What kinds of writing do you think you will encounter, and knowing this, how will you use your skills from English 1020 to continue your success as a writer?









Remember back at the beginning of the semester when I told you about the AP Nerd.  Here's one rearing her head...



Here's a gem from the I'm-not-brown-nosing-but-really-I-am-a-brown-noser.


When you were in college would you have dared to turn in a formal, final project in one of these folders?

Me either.


This has made my list of all-time favorites.  You'll have to look closely, but the black ink is mine.  The blue ink is his. Here was his awesome run-on that even he scribbled over before turning in the censorship essay for final revision.

"Someone that is not as psychologically unwavering as this one girl could have taken a situation of this magnitude the wrong way to the point of becoming mentally unstable much like Plato's allegory of the cave the man freaks out and chooses to go back inside the cave making him ponder what is actually real in this life, what he has known forever or what happens to be beyond the point of the cave?"






For realz?

I try to be kind and constructive in my feedback on papers like his.  What I really want to do is just CARVE three huge letters into the paper.

W.T.H.? (heck)

x

I'm really proud of the proofreading and editing skills of this potential English major. I also love the repetitive use of "writing skills" (which he doesn't really have) in the same paragraph.


Ugh.


One gal used a bobby-pin as her method of choice for attaching her papers to one another. Handy? Yes. Sanitary. Not so much.



I love, love, love to get papers like these that take for-ever to grade. They have more problems than I can possibly address in a single sitting/day/week/month/semester.




The question for consideration was, "how do you see yourself as a writer in the academic discipline for which you are majoring?"






But yes, I'd agree, not a lot of academic discipline here.

And you? In other words, you plagiarized.


And you, are you talking about underwear or writing?


Finally, one smart kid. =)











1 comment:

Teresa said...

Wow...and these are college students?